Book or film? Which order is best?

Chat about anything

Is it better to read a book before seeing the film or vice versa?

Book before film?
12
71%
Film before book?
5
29%
 
Total votes: 17

Message
Author
stuartboy
Se7en
Se7en
Posts: 4680
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 6:21 pm
Old post count: 0
Location: Edinburgh

Book or film? Which order is best?

#1 Post by stuartboy » Sat Nov 02, 2013 11:19 pm

Apologies if this has appeared before. Even more apologies if it was me who asked before. Lol. Also it's been a while since we had a pole so....

...I can never remember which way round is recommended. I think the concensus is that it is better to use one's imagination when reading a book rather than having the memory of visuals from a film colour your picturing of a book. On the other hand, a reading of a book following seeing the film can allow you to fill in details that the author can put forward that it is impossible to portray in a film.

I have made a point of not seeing any Harry Potter until I finally finish the books. Likewise the same for Lord of The Rings. I did b*y all of these on DVD when they came out so I have that treat to look forward to. The result of this is that I have no idea what Gandalf or Dumbledore look like. Obviously I can't but know what Ron Weasley or Harry look like cos they look like Rupert Grint and Danny Rad!

The incentive for this is the imminance of Hunger Games Bit 2 coming out soon. I b*ght the trilogy of books after enjoying the first film, and read book 1. Should I read book 2 before or after seeing the film in a few weeks?
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2017" club. 20 different films seen.
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2016" club. 93 different films seen.
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2015" club. 132 different films seen
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2014" club. 128 different films seen
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2013" club. 125 different films seen
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2012" club. 128 different films seen
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2011" club. 120 different films seen


Cineworld Unlimited is cheating! ;-)


Sometimes I sits and thinks....and sometimes I just sits.

User avatar
chelle1973
The Sixth Sense
The Sixth Sense
Posts: 1148
Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2012 6:01 pm
Old post count: 0
Preferred Cinemas: Any cinemas in Edinburgh and The Lothians.
I haven't got tickets for: Interested in all upcoming screenings.
Location: Edinburgh

Re: Book or film? Which order is best?

#2 Post by chelle1973 » Sat Nov 02, 2013 11:53 pm

I always prefer reading the books first, however while on holiday i read Filth, after seeing the film a few wks back........i'm quite glad i saw the film first! But of course more details are always in books and you really can get carried away with the character/s.
Preferred cinemas: Any in Edinburgh!

Member No.36 of the "100 free films in 2019". 4 seen
Member No.36 of the "100 free films in 2018". 11 seen
Member No.36 of the "100 free films in 2017". 8 seen
Member No.36 of the "100 free films in 2016". 15 seen
Member No.36 of the "100 free films in 2015". 39 seen
Member No.36 of the "100 free films in 2014". 33 seen

Sunny Saver
Se7en
Se7en
Posts: 4186
Joined: Thu Apr 15, 2010 7:24 am
Old post count: 0
Preferred Cinemas: Islington Vue, Holloway, Central London

Re: Book or film? Which order is best?

#3 Post by Sunny Saver » Sun Nov 03, 2013 7:55 am

Hmm, hard to say, if you do book first, you could sit through the film thinking, this isn't in book. If you do film first, you might think CBA read book now, as I've seen the film.

So you should add another option: either book or film, not both.

User avatar
claire
The Sixth Sense
The Sixth Sense
Posts: 1928
Joined: Wed Dec 08, 2010 6:48 pm
Old post count: 0
Preferred Cinemas: westfieldlondon /shepherds bush / hammersmith/ wandsworth/whitleys/ west end / wimbledon
Location: West london

Re: Book or film? Which order is best?

#4 Post by claire » Sun Nov 03, 2013 8:00 am

I normally see film first. As everyone always seems to say film is no where near as good as the book
Then I still enjoy both o/
Member 58 of the "100 free films in 2013" club
64seen 36 to go

member No.58 of the "100 free films in 2012" club
57 seen
Member No. 64 of the "100 free films in 2011" club.

User avatar
moggers
The Sixth Sense
The Sixth Sense
Posts: 1173
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2009 10:02 pm
Old post count: 404
Preferred Cinemas: Odeon Braehead, Odeon Quay, Cineworld Glasgow.
Location: Glasgow

Re: Book or film? Which order is best?

#5 Post by moggers » Sun Nov 03, 2013 10:48 am

Film before book for me, I get too involved with the book and find fault with the film if I have read before.

User avatar
canadian_turtle
9 1/2 Weeks
9 1/2 Weeks
Posts: 11405
Joined: Thu Dec 02, 2010 9:40 am
Old post count: 0
Preferred Cinemas: Wood Green, Islington, West End/Soho, Camden, Holloway, Hackney
Location: Under my duvet
Contact:

Re: Book or film? Which order is best?

#6 Post by canadian_turtle » Sun Nov 03, 2013 11:04 am

I normally read the book first for the simple fact that I read a lot of books and very often nowadays after I've already read them they're turned into a film.

I think it's more advisable the other way around though because 99% of the time the book is better than the film so by reading the book first you're setting yourself up for disappointment when seeing the film. Plus if you see the film first and liked it, reading the book after often provides more details to expand your knowledge on the story.
:star: www.pagetostagereviews.com :star:

Cinemas in order of preference: West End/Central London, Wood Green, Islington, Finchley Road
• (32/2014, 81/2013, 95/2012, 76/2011)

stuartboy
Se7en
Se7en
Posts: 4680
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 6:21 pm
Old post count: 0
Location: Edinburgh

Re: Book or film? Which order is best?

#7 Post by stuartboy » Sun Nov 03, 2013 12:04 pm

Eep! Seems relatively balanced on either side so far, argument-wise, surprisingly.
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2017" club. 20 different films seen.
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2016" club. 93 different films seen.
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2015" club. 132 different films seen
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2014" club. 128 different films seen
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2013" club. 125 different films seen
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2012" club. 128 different films seen
Member No. 49 of the "100 free films in 2011" club. 120 different films seen


Cineworld Unlimited is cheating! ;-)


Sometimes I sits and thinks....and sometimes I just sits.

caitlinmorton

Re: Book or film? Which order is best?

#8 Post by caitlinmorton » Mon Nov 04, 2013 1:58 pm

I almost feel like it depends on the particular book/film combo. Sometimes I see a film and then find out there was a book, or there's a book I didn't think I'd like and then seeing the film changes my mind. I look at it on a case by case basis, if that makes sense?

User avatar
Beate
The Modfather (& Three-Time Prediction Master!)
The Modfather (& Three-Time Prediction Master!)
Posts: 22013
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2009 4:26 pm
Old post count: 6588
Preferred Cinemas: West India Quay, Greenwich, Surrey Quays + Central London (Vue Islington, Apollo, Odeon Covent Garden, Cine Haymarket, Leicester Sq/West End)
Location: London
Contact:

Re: Book or film? Which order is best?

#9 Post by Beate » Mon Nov 04, 2013 2:00 pm

Well sometimes it's film only - I couldn't get into the Cloud Atlas book at all, and as for Great Expectations, I still have to read that either.
:popcorn: Member No. 1 of the "100 free films in 2020" club. 7 seen :popcorn:
o/ Member No. 1 of the "100 free films in 2009 - 2019" clubs. 826 seen o/
Image Member No. 1 of the "104 free previews in 2008" club. 92 seen
Image

User avatar
prettyxcool
8 1/2
8 1/2
Posts: 9944
Joined: Tue Aug 25, 2009 11:37 pm
Old post count: 0
Preferred Cinemas: Prefer all Central London, then Islington, Notting Hill, Whiteleys, Shepherd's Bush, Westfield, Holloway, Swiss Cottage, Clapham, WIQ, Greenwich 02, Surrey Quays, Fulham.
Location: London

Re: Book or film? Which order is best?

#10 Post by prettyxcool » Mon Nov 04, 2013 2:26 pm

canadian_turtle wrote:I normally read the book first for the simple fact that I read a lot of books and very often nowadays after I've already read them they're turned into a film.

I think it's more advisable the other way around though because 99% of the time the book is better than the film so by reading the book first you're setting yourself up for disappointment when seeing the film. Plus if you see the film first and liked it, reading the book after often provides more details to expand your knowledge on the story.
I agree with c_t. I recently read How I Live Now and the film came out shortly after, which I, of course, had not known before reading the book, and it just kept me from watching the film, as I could not help comparing it. However, if the film came out ages after having read the book, then it is fine for me, as I would not remember it in so much detail, to compare. But given the choice, I like to read the books afterwards, then it helps to explain or expand on parts that I wanted to know more about.
Member No. 17 of the "100 free films in 2019" club. 50 seen so far
My Movie Scores click here

2018 - 100 seen (9 premieres/Press) Also 2 Opera, 1 Netfix, 15 theatres, 2 concerts, 1 ballet)
2017 - 106 seen
2016 - 116 seen
2015 - 120 seen (16 premieres, 2 Gala Screenings). Also 3 theatres/shows, 2 concerts
2014 - 132 seen (26 premieres and 7 Gala Screenings). Also 18 misc. free events/concerts
2013 - 115 Seen (12 premieres). Also 6 theatres/shows, 5 concerts
2012 - 118 seen (23 premieres). Also 12 theatres/shows.
2011 - 133 seen
2010 - 105 seen


Post Reply